I reread my post and I did not see a cheap shot there. I do believe there are no easy solutions and unless whatever this group has in mind will increase the price of live cattle or direct returns to the producer it is not a solution at all. It would be wonderful if it did, as I said I like an easy answer as much as the next fellow, and I look forward to their announcement on February 21. After reading rkaisers post I made arrangements to be at the Alberta Beef Industry Conference in Red Deer, I am interested in hearing their ideas.
I know nothing of what happened at a particular ABP producer meeting. And I am not Mr. ABP in these threads even if rksaiser likes to make out I am. I have absolutely no idea what did or did not go on in this B5 group, who attended or who did not attend and why other than rkaisers posts in these threads. I gather from the post at the top of this thread that ABP is still considering whatever proposal came out of the process.
Regarding any proposal the B5 group and others like them might come up with, if it involves sound ideas they will go forward. The WSGA and I think some of the others in rkaisers B5 group are already involved and part of ABP, including rkaiser himself. You bet there are good people in the WSGA, I recall Hugh Lynch Staunton came into ABP as a WSGA delegate and now he is the head of CCA. There is no culture of arrogance at ABP. For the most part they try not to swear when speaking in public, that is about it. Unfortunately it is part and parcel of the cattle business that you will not agree with every producer all the time. The ideas are so varied and solutions so hard to find.
I see people come into ABP and learn about the cattle industry. There is a lot to know. Everyone there is a cattle producer too. Some people choose to work for the industry in other organizations, like the WSGA or the Cattle Feeders and that is fine too. Some stay home and let others do it. Trying to improve the lot of the grass roots cattle producer is a lot of work and most solutions take years of work to see them actually happen.
I know nothing of what happened at a particular ABP producer meeting. And I am not Mr. ABP in these threads even if rksaiser likes to make out I am. I have absolutely no idea what did or did not go on in this B5 group, who attended or who did not attend and why other than rkaisers posts in these threads. I gather from the post at the top of this thread that ABP is still considering whatever proposal came out of the process.
Regarding any proposal the B5 group and others like them might come up with, if it involves sound ideas they will go forward. The WSGA and I think some of the others in rkaisers B5 group are already involved and part of ABP, including rkaiser himself. You bet there are good people in the WSGA, I recall Hugh Lynch Staunton came into ABP as a WSGA delegate and now he is the head of CCA. There is no culture of arrogance at ABP. For the most part they try not to swear when speaking in public, that is about it. Unfortunately it is part and parcel of the cattle business that you will not agree with every producer all the time. The ideas are so varied and solutions so hard to find.
I see people come into ABP and learn about the cattle industry. There is a lot to know. Everyone there is a cattle producer too. Some people choose to work for the industry in other organizations, like the WSGA or the Cattle Feeders and that is fine too. Some stay home and let others do it. Trying to improve the lot of the grass roots cattle producer is a lot of work and most solutions take years of work to see them actually happen.
Comment