grassfarmer?

[PureCountry]

What the Hell is with this continuing crap about young farmers have no hope? I'm bloody sick of it cowman!! There is plenty of hope and a future in farming or ranching if you do it right. You don't need a 2-MILLION dollar set of equipment to live a good life in agriculture. You don't need 5,000 acres to have a good life in agriculture. You don't need a $50,000 truck, $250,000 house, and all the creature comforts, to have A GOOD LIFE IN AGRICULTURE.

You SHOULD be encouraging young farmers. We all should be. I'm tired of listening to your constant BS about how young farmers are crazy to get into it. Yeah their crazy to do it the way I just described above, but there are many ways to live a 'good life' in farming and ranching without taking the risk of all those inputs.

If all you can say about young people in farming is doom and gloom, shut the Hell up and stick to talking about other things.

[Cattleman]

I sort of have to agree with you purecountry.....all farmers do is complain about how bad everything is, (because farming like their grandfather doesn't work anymore) and then they wonder why no young people want to get into agriculture. All businesses change, and many people in agriculture are very resistant to change which is causing all the problems. I myself see so many opportunities of producing many great products off the land, whether it be sod, direct marketed beef, horse market oats, and small square bales, pet industry products, the list can go on forever. Things are going quite fine at our place, and I am young. Don't look at the negative all thr time and look at the positive! I am not directing these comments towards just cowman, but many of the people involved in agriculture today.

[smcgrath76]

I tend to agree with all of the posts (including cowman) above.
I am a young producer, who generates most of my income off farm as a means to cash flow expansion. I think the math is fiarly straightforward. If you want a $50,000 a year income from 50 cows, then you need to figure out how to clear $1000 a cow, otherwise you need more cows. As a youngster I am concerned about return on equity/assets, especially since I don't have a whole bunch at this stage in the game, but I also need cash to do things like buy groceries.
My PERSONAL opinion about the lifestyle argument is that everyone has a lifestyle. A bum on the street pushing a shopping cart has a lifestyle, a young farmer using their visa card to buy groceries and not knowing how they will pay it off has a lifestyle, Donald Trump has a lifestyle. A lifestyle of high debt, low cash flow is a pretty crappy one in my opinion and not one that I particularly want to undertake. With that in mind I(we) structure our business and our decisions such that we can take that into account.
Do I need to own land, or do I want to own land? Do I need to own cows to be a cowboy or a rancher? Am I the only person who can take care of my cows, put up feed, etc.? Where do I get the best return on my time vs. where do I like to spend my time?

These are the kind of things that I continually ask myself (Agri-ville helps). Somethings get done just because I like to do them, others because I know that they pay better for the time I invest than anything else I can do.

There are opportunities in agriculture, but the mindset of established and young producers cannot remain the same.
I agree with cowman in the strict commodity sense of the game that it is nearly impossible to do starting with debt (no equity). We are lucky in that we are building off of an established operation and can be a bit creative and search out some new opportunities to hopefully go around some of the issues that exist in the live cattle business.

[smcgrath76]

lifestyle and necessities sometimes are not one and the same. Wanting the $50,000 pickup might correlate with a chosen lifestyle, but heating the modest home, putting food on the table and clothes on the kids are necessities. A young neighbour wanted to farm full time with his father, he bought into the farm which they expanded by another section of land, they also expanded their cowherd, the kid got married had a couple of little ones and then BSE hit.
He and his wife are still living in the old mobile home that they bought as a STARTER home, they aren't heading out on the weekends to quad, ski or snowmobile with their friends, they drive the same old pickup that the kid bought new before wife and kids.
They seem to be weathering the storm but there must be times when they are damn envious of the lifestyles of their friends. And things don't really look like they are going to get a lot easier for them and lots like them. Puts a lot of pressure on a young couple, and likely makes him second guess his choice to farm with dad.

[ALLFARMER]

Cowman is bang on with his comments on new farmers. Plain and simple! Anyone who thinks its just roses has been temp testing cattle to long. A good friend of mine had the balls and thought he knew better than everyone else, that was 2 years ago...when he still had 2 big air seeders lots of owned & rented land 100 plus cows a house with a wife & young doughter. Today he rents an old trailer on a acreage & lives in the oilpatch. How he keeps goin I don't know. Another friend has given up 3 of his 5 quarters before he loses it all, and he was not long ago set up by his dad.

I could continue with these story's for a while because I know another 5!!!!! farmers who are looking at similar pictures. And yet I don't know 1 young farm couple who doesn't have significant off farm income keeping them afloat. FARMING IF YOUR LUCKY (VERY LUCKY) PAYS ITS OWN WAY - END OF STORY.

[Cattleman]

Well I never said this was an easy business, and the success rate is probably lower other self-owned businesses, but not all. You can look at the failing businesses around you....but not much you can learn from them....I have three neighbours (in Saskatchewan) who either started with very little or have expanded a lot in the last 10 years (one does significant off farm income) but one neighbour is a sharp sharp feedlot, and he said last year was his best year ever. Many know him to know his numbers as good as any in the industry, so he is always upbeat about what he is doing next. The other is a cow-calf operator, who had 20 cows 10 years ago, and who will ahve about 220 this spring. These guys are not doing anything even that special really, just managing costs. So it is your choice to dwell on the negative versus the positive.
I am not saying your are going to get rich raising calves and wheat, but if you want to get the higher return on investment, invest up the value chain versus those same things that are pretty much guaranteed a low rate of return. I am concerned as well about my rate of return, but I am not asking for the $60,000 pay for something I love to do. My after tax take home pay is satisfying enough for me. I have lived in a city as well and disposable income can sure dissappear fast there too.

[greybeard]

Again, I have to vote with farmers-son. Agriculture is still an honorable profession to participate in. We aren’t eating out of garbage cans.
If I lived on the Highway 2 corridor, I may see things differently. A very buoyant oilfield influences Land prices there. It is also seen as a very attractive place to live because of the proximity to urban services. The best of both worlds, so to speak.
When comparing agriculture to oilfield, you have to remember one is in the midst of the greatest boom ever, and the other may be in one of the greatest busts ever. But they are both commodities, and both will cycle.
I know guys that have started with nothing but good management skills and a sensible
Lifestyle. I also know some who lost everything their fathers handed over to them. They had the assets but not the management skills.
This thread started about Grassfarmer. Maybe Cowman was just trying to bait him out?
Didn’t you come here because you saw Canadian agriculture as a better opportunity than Scotland, even if Scotland offered higher prices for your product?
I have a friend who is in Alberta making $75 hr welding oilfield tanks, but I know he would rather be at home making hay.
Cowman and me are about the same age and think a lot alike. We need some more of Grass farmers “holistic” training. Then we won’t need that $75 hr to enjoy life.

[greybeard]

we don't need $75.00 an hour to enjoy life but even a holistic farmer needs to have a roof over their head and some means of transportation both of which are getting more costlier to own by the day.
I think by and large farmers are a more frugal sort,which helps get them through the rough spots like the one we're in now. With the oilpatch job comes added expenses, living in resource based communities usually means higher cost of living so its not all gravy.

[blackjack]

...but there is one big difference between farming now than 25 years ago...when the cycle of better returns happened the farmer was able to put more away in the old nest egg account...now because of higher taxes you had better be sharp to keep it cause our govt(at all levels) just love to think they can spend it more wisely than you...

... one of the reasons the industry needs you young guys is the experience...not only to do the work but to how to manage...back a few years the farmer could do a few poor decisions and get away with it...I agree with you guys that want to move up the value chain but remember partnerships (even with family ) can run in to it's difficulties...

[blackjack]

goood advice, blackjack. If land ownership is involved and the family partnerships end up in the middle of a divorce it can really causes havoc.