• You will need to login or register before you can post a message. If you already have an Agriville account login by clicking the login icon on the top right corner of the page. If you are a new user you will need to Register.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Wheat and Durum Quality: Please Explain this!

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Wheat and Durum Quality: Please Explain this!

    Charlie,

    I just read the; "Glenn, Divide top wheat varieties in North Dakota

    (World-Grain.com, July 22, 2010)
    by World Grain Staff"

    If 'designated area' milling wheat quality is the best is the world... then why is there not one variety of wheat or durum... grown in the US... right across the fence row... from Canadian wheat and durum?

    And why year after year... do US growers growing the same protein and grain clean of fusarium... earn premium prices to CWB returns?

    Why can't I reconcile this with CWB propaganda???


    "Glenn, Divide top wheat varieties in North Dakota

    (World-Grain.com, July 22, 2010)
    by World Grain Staff"
    "MANDAN, NORTH DAKOTA, U.S. — The 2010 North Dakota wheat variety survey shows that Glenn hard red spring wheat and Divide durum are again the most popular variety choices for producers, the North Dakota Wheat Commission announced July 19.

    Glenn accounted for one-fourth of the 6.7 million acres of hard red spring wheat planted and Divide claimed 27%t of the 1.8 million acres planted to durum. In the hard red winter wheat class, Jerry continued to dominate acres with 48% of the 340,000 acres planted. The results are based on a June survey of approximately 2,200 producers conducted by the North Dakota Field Office of the U.S. Department of Agriculture's National Agricultural Statistics Service. Funding for the survey was provided by the North Dakota Wheat Commission and the North Dakota State University (NDSU) Agriculture Experiment Station.

    The top two varieties, Glenn and Faller, account for 40% of total acreage, with Kelby, RB 07 and Briggs rounding out the top five. Glenn has been the leading variety in North Dakota since 2007. It remains popular for its balanced agronomics and disease resistance traits, and comparatively higher protein levels. A plus for customers is its superior milling and baking quality.

    Faller is again second despite a slight decline in acres. It accounts for 15% of the acres and is most popular in the eastern one-third of the state. Faller is one of the elite varieties for yield potential and foliar disease resistance, but it is typically lower in protein content. Both varieties are NDSU releases.

    Kelby advanced to third position this year with 6.4% of the acres, up slightly from last year due to its competitive yield and higher protein levels. An AgriPro release, it is the top variety in east-central North Dakota.

    The remaining top 10 varieties all were fairly even in their percent of acres planted, ranging from 3% to 5%. RB 07, a release from the University of Minnesota, had the largest net gain in acres of all varieties, increasing from 1.3% to 4.9%, moving it into fourth position. It is a strong yielding variety which has excellent milling and baking qualities that gained acres in eastern districts as well as the southwest. Other varieties that made gains this year include Brennan, Jenna, Breaker, Barlow, Choteau, Mercury and Vantage, slowly replacing long-time popular varieties like Reeder, Alsen, Freyr and Briggs.

    Divide remains the leading durum variety followed by Mountrail, Lebsock, Alkabo and Pierce. The top five are the same as last year and all are releases from NDSU. Divide had the largest net gain in acres in 2010, finding favor with producers in all of the major durum districts. It is a variety that is near the top for yield and disease resistant traits, and also has good end-use quality characteristics.

    Mountrail and Lebsock account for roughly 25% of the acres combined, but this is down from their peak of nearly 60% in 2006. Other varieties that are replacing some of those acres include Alkabo, Grenora and DG Max, a release from Dakota Growers Pasta Company, with 9.5%, 7% and 2% of the acres, respectively."

    The CWB says they can't compete with premium US prices (I remember 6 years ago... the CWB management told us they could beat US prices any time).

    So... with all the regulations... propaganda... and millions upon millions in research spent by 'designated area' wheat and durum growers...

    Why are we earning discount prices (to US grown wheat durum and barley) for our CWB grains... and premium or at least equivelent prices for our 'non-board grains' grown in western Canada? Where have we gone wrong???

    #2
    You ask why and where we have gone wrong. Its because you, I and everyone else won't band together to support what is fair and right for everyone. Collective and socialist and coop immediately spring to mind and the necessary discussion never even gets started.
    So your concerns; which should be my concerns gain no traction. You and the rest of us will someday day realize we will continue to be picked off as individuals because we have next to no power in the big scheme of things.
    And governments will support and sustain farming to the extent they decide. You'll beg and whine like a common pan handler; not ever be a truly proud farmer.

    Comment


      #3
      Tom. I have to agree with the nd farmer. 80%of my hrswht is also Glenn. We will see what kind of protein levels it has after 22"of rain since planting.

      Comment


        #4
        rbrunel,

        Very interesting!

        How do you market the Glenn... I assume not through normal Canadian CWRS deliveries? Does the Glenn end up back in the USA?

        The only way to close the yeild, quality and price gap... is to work together with US wheat growers... instead of our most recent habit of treating them with ignorance and distain!

        Comment


          #5
          rbrunel,

          I see Glenn IS registered in Canada.

          Only fair sprouting resitance or we would grow it!

          It is totally obvious that US and 'designated area' red spring wheat quality is a match... other than our sprout problems when it rains at harvest!

          Comment

          • Reply to this Thread
          • Return to Topic List
          Working...