HAVE WE ACCEPTED??

[charliep]

No disagreement that canola seed is expensive. I note that farmers (as
indicated by the discussion here) are aware of and pretty good at keeping
their costs down. If the value weren't there, then canola acres would be
decreasing or farmers would be using conventional seed. Less than 1 % of
the Alberta canola grown conventional. A source estimated about 52 %
roundup ready, 42 % liberty link and about 5 % clearfield.

Starting in 2011, the discussion has indicated this may start to happen. The
market places function will be to ensure this doesn't happen via price and
other means. The canola industry will compete for your acres next spring.

On the cereal side, the market doesn't seem to care. Participants up the
supply chain know you have to grow cereals for crop rotation reasons.
Limited needs for the human food market/domestic processing. Lots of
options for the feed market starting with US corn/distillers grains. No need
for creativity or innovation. Just happens.

[silverback]

How many do you suppose would have advocated at that time for the forced pooling of their neighbors produce?

[parsley]

1921 Saskatchewan Election Results:
47 Liberals
3 Conservative
7 Independent
6 Progressives

[stubblejumper]

Grain growers' associations are a group of farm organizations formed on the Prairies in the early 20th century. They developed in the wake of the Manitoba Grain Act (July 1900), which regulated railways and grain elevators in the interests of grain growers. This Act, the result of considerable agitation in rural areas since the late 1880s, was regarded by farmers as a major victory. But dissatisfaction with the handling of the 1901 bumper crop led farmers at Indian Head (in present-day Saskatchewan) to convene a meeting in December 1901, at which the Territorial Grain Growers' Association was formed. The Manitoba Grain Growers' Association, established 1903 at Virden, followed. In 1906 the Territorial Grain Growers' Association was divided into the Saskatchewan Grain Growers' Association and the Alberta Farmers' Association. The latter joined with the Canadian Society of Equity to create the UNITED FARMERS OF ALBERTA in 1909. In 1920 the Manitoba Grain Growers' Association was reorganized as the UNITED FARMERS OF MANITOBA in an attempt to gain the support of all farmers and to proclaim an intention to enter politics. The Saskatchewan Grain Growers' Association amalgamated with the Farmers' Union of Canada in 1926 to create the militant UNITED FARMERS OF CANADA (Saskatchewan Section).

Keywords

West & Northwest HistoryGrain growers' associations were powerful spokesmen for the Prairies and Canadian agriculture generally. They lobbied provincial and federal governments for reform of the grain-marketing system and improvement of rural life. They sponsored the development of 3 large farmer-owned grain-marketing organizations, the Grain Growers' Grain Co (1906), the Saskatchewan Co-operative Elevator Co (1911) and the Alberta Farmers' Co-operative Elevator Co (1913). They published the GRAIN GROWERS' GUIDE 1908-28, which was the main voice of western agriculture until the mid-1920s. The associations agitated for better roads, schools and medical care for the countryside.
Particularly responsive to the plight of rural women, they embraced WOMEN'S SUFFRAGE and helped to win the vote for women on the Prairies during WWI. Technically, the associations were politically neutral, but some early leaders, such as Liberals C.A. DUNNING, W.R. MOTHERWELL and T.A. CRERAR, achieved national political prominence. Politics, however, was a vexing issue for the associations and was one of the reasons they disappeared after farmers began to assert themselves and demand a more direct voice in the political process.

[silverback]

Interesting, lots of voluntary associations and cooperation. They even advocated strongly for the rights of their wives, mothers, and children to vote.

Now, all these years later, some of their descendants work very hard to make sure their neighbors, not to mention their own childrens, freedoms are restricted.

I'm sure they would be very proud.