More on Hudye Farms...

[agriman]

I can tell you that this is a case of unbridled
Retribution. Hudye is too big of an operator for
the wheat boards comfort level. He has to be cut
down to size, just as the young man in the
YouTube video must not be allowed to get a
toehold. The wheat board is the new Stasi.
Hudye deserves your support, not your second
guessing.

[bucket]

Can someone explain how blending out 122 tonnes of unregistered hrsw is any different than blending out fusarium infected feed wheat into a milling grade??

The cwb promotes the practice every year, and bypasses CGC regulations in doing so.

[TOM4CWB]

Bucket,

Or what about the tens of thousands of tonnes of winter wheat that gets blended into our CWRS every year.

At the very worst... the CERS registered variety could easily have been blended as a contrasting class like CPS or CWRW to meet spec for CWRS shipment.

[GALAXIE500]

This is an interesting story about Hudye Farms. The ironic thing is that every elevator out there blends some sort of off grade junk in their cars when they ship them . I know this because I worked for Sask Pool for 12 years, and thats how we got most of our grade gains / slush fund for the year! There were times when we would put cps, grandin, w wheat, etc into every car that went out, all within tolerances, but still it made the company money. How it works now I don't know, because I have not been there for 8 years. I am sure they still do it. The system we have doesnt like Hudye because they are beating them at their own game, and Hudye got caught.

[furrowtickler]

Exactly galaxie, I would bet every elevator point in western canada does this at some level with the wheat boards approval.

[bucket]

Seems the judge might look at the practice of blending and throw the whole thing out with costs.

How is the cwb going to defend this by saying "we don't blend" when their own website promotes it and the changing of CGC standards to do so?

[Jay-mo]

I think Galaxie may have nailed it. Hudye has been playing the same game the elevators and the CWB do as a regular course of business. That is, blending in varieties within normally acceptable limits.
That would explain the malisciousness of the CWB's action against Hudye's contract.

[wmoebis]

Not sticking up for either side here.

The differance here is NON REG variety. Yes you can blend classes or varieties up to grade spec but not 'non reg varieties'.

Ask any elevator manager they will tell you the same. Elevators do it and some farmers blend on the farm wooc's and ocg's up to grade spec.

[TOM4CWB]

wmoebis

Blending in high fusarium into our wheat that is clean...

Totally vindicates and justifies what Hudye Farms did with 606/Granite.

THere is nothing wrong with this wheat... just as there is nothing wrong with every other wheat variety registered in the US as DNS. The price they acheive proves I am right.

What the CWB and CGC are doing is just belligerent and vindictive.

If a wheat sale spec is not variety specific like Warburtons... then if it is a DNS CERS or CWRS... it mills.

If a certain variety is specified... a premium needs to be paid... then a complaint is legit if not supplied.

[wmoebis]

Tom

When a customer orders CWRS they are guaranteed wheat of certain registered varieties that will be in that class and grade. Non registered varieties can only be graded as feed wheat.

So in a manor of speaking, every sale is variety specific to that class and grade. The CFIA recomends the varieties the CGC liscences and guarantees them the CWB sells them and it farmers responsabiliy to supply them.

I said when the Triffid flax thing happened it would only be time before the same thing happened in wheat and it did. Thankfully it was caught before it hit the customer.

This is nothing new, there have been farmers trying to slip off non reg varieties before. Some get caught some don't I suppose. It is just that Hudye is trying to make a point and I am not going to judge that right or wrong. I am just glad the system works, before more of our markets got wrecked.

If I order a Ford truck I expect it to come with a Ford engine not a Chev engine. Even tho it would make it a better truck.

[bucket]

wmoebis

Do you want to explain the fusarium program?

Feed wheat is feed wheat. Except when the cwb changes the cgc standards.

Are you also saying western canadian wheat doesn't get mixed up with eastern canadian wheat at the eastern port?

You really can't be that naive to think there isn't blending going on with all varieties at the port either on purpose or by accident?

And then consider how short the cwb is of high quality cwrs, it is almost a certainty that eatern, western, and american grain is being blended.

Remember that 400,000 tonnes of american hrs that ended up in canada a few months ago? The cwb wasn't selling it, the grain was just passing through the system.

The cwb has got a real fight that may be pretty hard to defend.

[wmoebis]

I would encourage you to do a Google search, ask your elevator market rep or phone the CWB to ask your fusarium question. I understand it, but maybe better explained by the ones who admin it.

I do understand the controled blending system, that accidents happen and how they are delt with.