Malt vs Feed

[FarmRanger]

Not the bogus comparison to supply
management again.  

Supply management:  brought about by an
overwhelming majority of producers of the time of
it's conception.  However I'll conceived at the
time (drastically increasing the prices to
consumers while having the subsidies ultimately
exiting the industry with the sale of quota), this
subsidy did benefit the producers of the time.  
Compare prices on either side of the border to
see the effectiveness.

CWB single desk: brought about by government
with no plebiscite of those forced under it's
mandate.  High degree of self promotion, but no
demonstrable price benefit to the producer.  In
fact, all evidence shows that being the only
buyer, and one of many sellers in the world has
only given the CWB the ability to reduce prices
by being able to source grain no matter how low
a price they end up paying us.  Once again,
compare prices on either side of the border to
see the effectiveness.

Comparing supply management and the CWB is
like comparing oranges and apples.  
Or more aptly, oranges and road apples.

I'll be more comfortable Aug. 1, 2012

[gregpet]

Doesn't look like any dancing there chuckchuck.
Now tell us why the CWB is so good. Where is your
proof? The prices and price signals I see do not bode
well for the CWB.

[parsley]

chukchuck forgot to mention that Ontario Directors did npt democratically vote to end Ontario's participation in the CWB monopoly in 1947 that they were part of.

No, indeed.

The MP's carefully used Parliament to take everyone out of the monopoly, except the West; and they named it the Designated Area.

Legislation. Government bestows and takes away.

If you're of that age, chuckchuck, you must have bawled in your hankie that you didn't get a vote to keep Ontario and Quebec in the CWB.

[Hopperbin]

Chuckchuck this should only be about us western farmers under cwb controle not about any supply management issue.

[FarmForProfit]

So can the Designated Area just be
reduced to the City of Winnipeg? I'm
getting tired of the endless whining and
wrangling of the CWB with my money.

They are screwed whether they admit it
or not. Even if they get a judge to
agree they have fewer supporters each
year and if there was a real vote (you
get 1 vote if you file a farm tax return
regardless of what you produce) they
would be in shock. Actually I'm pretty
sure they know what their real support
is they just won't admit it.
I'm not saying anybody but me should
decide what I do with my grain, just
saying their voting list is BS.

The CWB is screwed