4 Reasons why a there should not be a vote marketing choice.
1 The CWB is being completely disingenuous when they promote their farmer's decision by ballot. They totally ignored the barley vote.
2 The issue is tainted, just as judicial proceedures are moved to a different venue because a fair trial cannot be conducted. A fair vote on market choice could only be conducted if the choice side could spend millions for over a decade promoting freedom. (While using exaggerations, extrapolations and fabrications to make their point.) It can't be done!
3 An acceptable voters list would be impossible to construct. Just producers, by pemit book, I have two, others have more. Okay 1 per producer, do you equally weight the 80 acre guy with the 10,000 acre guy? And we have just disenfranchised those who could grow wheat and are growing other things because of the CWB. What about the landlords they have a stake too, then maybe agribusinesses, or the consumer, where do you stop!!!
4 You don't use plebicites to determine issues relating to individual rights or the rights of a minority, or to extending equality to other regions. This is because the majority by voting in their own interests can trample or ignore the rights of a minority.
That is the reason the govenment is elected to determine the actual realities involved in a decision, and decide on the basis what is most beneficial to the largest number of people, while protecting the rights and aspirations of the minority.
And that is exactly what the Federal government is doing, with the approval of the governments of Alberta and Saskatchewan. They know what is good for tax revenues.
Am I right ??
1 The CWB is being completely disingenuous when they promote their farmer's decision by ballot. They totally ignored the barley vote.
2 The issue is tainted, just as judicial proceedures are moved to a different venue because a fair trial cannot be conducted. A fair vote on market choice could only be conducted if the choice side could spend millions for over a decade promoting freedom. (While using exaggerations, extrapolations and fabrications to make their point.) It can't be done!
3 An acceptable voters list would be impossible to construct. Just producers, by pemit book, I have two, others have more. Okay 1 per producer, do you equally weight the 80 acre guy with the 10,000 acre guy? And we have just disenfranchised those who could grow wheat and are growing other things because of the CWB. What about the landlords they have a stake too, then maybe agribusinesses, or the consumer, where do you stop!!!
4 You don't use plebicites to determine issues relating to individual rights or the rights of a minority, or to extending equality to other regions. This is because the majority by voting in their own interests can trample or ignore the rights of a minority.
That is the reason the govenment is elected to determine the actual realities involved in a decision, and decide on the basis what is most beneficial to the largest number of people, while protecting the rights and aspirations of the minority.
And that is exactly what the Federal government is doing, with the approval of the governments of Alberta and Saskatchewan. They know what is good for tax revenues.
Am I right ??
Comment