Little Change to Alberta oil royalties

[perfecho]

It was a "Royalty Review" ..not a Royalty Change"...she had to eat some crow, but good for her...she did what she thought was best, it was needed.
Hopefully she doesn't do as many tax concessions to the oil guys, and we move on...
but in some eyes, she will never do any good until "their's" is back in power...
getting quite tired of Brian Jean's whining though....

[LEP]

Really Perfecho? A centrepiece of her campaign was that oil companies were stealing the oil and not paying their fair share.

I would say that convinced a lot of people to vote for her party.

So now you say "she ate some crow and it's all good".

Unbelievable. Next thing you know she will be giving everyone a raise... Oh she did that.

If you can't trust them to have researched the main point of their campaign, how can you trust anything they said.

[perfecho]

...so I take it you are one of the sore losers....
Not that I am a big fan, but I can live with it. Liked that she gave it to a panel to do ,,,,I have been getting the updates, as anyone who wanted could, and I am sure it was not easy to come to this conclusion...the conclusion could have been different at a different time, but think right now, its a very delicate subject. Glad there was a process, and I got my little say in the process.
She was "man" enough to step up...more than I can say about some....but then, she will never do any good in some eyes, so why bother....

[BFW]

Think it might be for of a case of "when money talks ideology walks" as much as anything.

[FarmRanger]

Repeating the NDP lie that "Albertans aren't getting their fair share" may get you elected, but it won't help your re-election when the centerpiece of your previous campaign was complete horse$#| .
#longmemories

[foragefarmer]

Farmranger

At $30/barrel oil, if the NDP had raised royalties , and with jobs being lost, you'd be the first on here screaming. They also have a few more years to act on this, so if oil goes up, maybe the royalties will then be raised.

I don't think the NDP could do anything that would please you Farmrange, along with others here on Agriville. How's the golf game?

[FarmRanger]

You did get one thing right forage, I would have condemned an increase in costs to an industry that is already bleeding. But that is irrelevant to a campaign promise that has turned out to be a false claim about the "fairness" of the Royalty structure. Remember, our premier agreed with the findings of the Royalty review. That same Review said that the amount that Royalties would increase with oil price increases was fair as well.

This is in direct contradiction to the NDP campaign which as it turns out was wrong. Elected on a promise to fix something that wasn't broken. Would have been nice if they'd bothered to investigate the truth about the Royalty structure at the time, but the lie that oil companies weren't paying their fair share was just too good not to use to get elected. These kinds of lies work exceptionally well at appealing to uninformed voter's greed. "Vote for us, we'll get you something for free at someone else's expense (who aren't paying their "fair" share and have more money than you).

<i>"How's the golf game?"</i>
My golf game sucks thanks, I keep losing the ball in the snow. How's your cabinet appointment going?

[perfecho]

Not broken...perhaps the royalty regime was ok (although I wonder what a $100 /barrel review would have looked like)..there is the other side, the pay backs....when Peter Elzinga, Klein's chair who helped him get re-elected, went to the oil sands as a consultant and suddenly more tax concessions began to appear...at $60 a barrel, which was pretty high at the time.
There were many articles, about how so many dollars went back, so this part is only half the story....

"For the second year in a row, Dunn still cannot understand why the Alberta Royalty Tax Credit program continues to dole out $82 million in royalty refunds despite record oil and gas prices.

Nor could he really understand the reasoning between royalty reduction programs that exempted, reduced or waived Crown royalties totaling $517 million last year."

...Dunn was auditor general at he time and there are many, many more articles. Just the fact that we are out of money before the governments changed hands should be a clue.

Now , I agree Notely is not Alberta's saviour, but I am still glad there is change....