I thought that 3.3 million interest on 8 million sounded excessive, but a quick calculation based on 3.5 years, and assuming the entire 8 million was the original capital, works out to just over 10% per year compounded.
It is probably worse than that, since the 8 million likely doesn't all date from 2014, but grew over the 3.5 years. But still not near payday loan rates. If one assumes they are lenders of last resort, and therefore taking on riskier loans, then getting at least double bank rates doesn't seem completely unreasonable.
But if they are secured by both land and grain, then the risk should be very low eventually, as compared to a payday loan.
Edit to add, that I negelcted to include grain already delivered under input capital's name, which is unknown to us. Assume that went to interest first, not principal, so the rate would be worse than 10%.
It is probably worse than that, since the 8 million likely doesn't all date from 2014, but grew over the 3.5 years. But still not near payday loan rates. If one assumes they are lenders of last resort, and therefore taking on riskier loans, then getting at least double bank rates doesn't seem completely unreasonable.
But if they are secured by both land and grain, then the risk should be very low eventually, as compared to a payday loan.
Edit to add, that I negelcted to include grain already delivered under input capital's name, which is unknown to us. Assume that went to interest first, not principal, so the rate would be worse than 10%.
Comment