Seed royalty

[Guest]

maybe the NFU is the way to go , I don't know ? they were the sole voice saying this seed monopoly/scam was wrong . maybe it's time to get some real money into that outfit.
all I know nothing is working now

[farmaholic]

I think we know there are "certified seed growers" that follow this site and have contributed posts to the forums in the past. What is their opinion on this subject. I realize slamming the seed growers is the wrong target because I believe it's the owner's to the rights of the seed that is the target.

Curious to see what they think.

[Oliver88]

maybe the NFU is the way to go , I don't know ? they were the sole voice saying this seed monopoly/scam was wrong . maybe it's time to get some real money into that outfit.
all I know nothing is working now

The problem with the NFU is it’s basically a wing of the NDP and has been taken over by the left fringe.
Your donation would end up supporting left wing loons like Teresa Spence and her fake hunger strike, union politics, bringing back the CWB and other nutty causes.

[tweety]

And yet half the country is covered with 12$ a pound canola seed and if the seed companies sold 20$ a pound, it would be sold out first.

What farmers say, and what farmers do are completely different and all the companies know just how vain you really are. Pay up sucker.

[farmaholic]

And yet half the country is covered with 12$ a pound canola seed and if the seed companies sold 20$ a pound, it would be sold out first.

What farmers say, and what farmers do are completely different and all the companies know just how vain you really are. Pay up sucker.

Do you realize that $12/lb. canola seed is more economical for some people in the high production areas that the low production areas. 60bu/ac versus 30..... but who's problem is that?

Edit in...

"SUCKER"?
The problem is we are supporting a myriad of useless fools who aren't contributing anything to the cause.... only taking!!!! And paying for exorbitant amount of advertising.

Very seldom have I had to be the first guy to have the newest and of course improved variety..... but I have been grudgingly dragged up to paying what they set their price up to by everyone who did have to have the latest and greatest.

[tweety]

Are you sure the variety is solely responsible for that 30 to 60 increase?

[farmaholic]

Are you sure the variety is solely responsible for that 30 to 60 increase?

Hell no tweety. Its area, rainfall and inputs. Just saying $12 seed makes more sense to the guy who can fairly cosistently grow 60.

[hobbyfrmr]

And yet half the country is covered with 12$ a pound canola seed and if the seed companies sold 20$ a pound, it would be sold out first.

What farmers say, and what farmers do are completely different and all the companies know just how vain you really are. Pay up sucker.

Im flashing back about 28 years watching aSaturday Night Live skit Dana Carvey was Johnny Carson and his chronically agreeable Sidekick Ed McMahon.

Yes, you are correct sir....uh ha ha.

[grassfarmer]

The problem with the NFU is it’s basically a wing of the NDP and has been taken over by the left fringe.
Your donation would end up supporting left wing loons like Teresa Spence and her fake hunger strike, union politics, bringing back the CWB and other nutty causes.

One thing about the NFU - it's what its members want it to be. It's run as a democracy with the people in power elected by the members and the issues they pursue are the ones their members want them to pursue. Unlike most "commodity groups" i've encountered in western Canada the fact that they aren't a mouth piece of government or corporate interests sets them apart.

[ajl]

Hell no tweety. Its area, rainfall and inputs. Just saying $12 seed makes more sense to the guy who can fairly cosistently grow 60.

Nobody consistently grows 60 except in Hutt bushels. That is the first misconception to be rid of. All the input suppliers out there like to make you think your competition does. The good land around here will consistently do 50 but there are years that it does not make that either for a variety of reasons usually flooding. If you seed an acres but gets flooded out after, I include that acre in my yield calculations as the inputs were committed even though it was not harvested.