I could possibly support a UBI under the following conditions.
If the stated purpose is:
1) to shrink government, not grow government.
2)Eliminate every other social program
3)Eliminate most of the civil service who otherwise would be administering those programs
4)Eliminate most labour laws, particularly minium wage
5)Oulaw labour unions, since they would no longer be necessary
6)Total spending would actually go down not up
7)It removes any possibilities of buying elections by promising more free stuff by increasingly taking it away from those who don't vote for them at every election. Governments can get back to governance, instead of redistribution.(Which sounds ironic given the topic, but if this was a one and done deal, then forever more, there would be no more freebie promises, instead of the creeping socialism we have now, where each party tries to out promise the other.
8)We find some way to keep everyone motivated in spite of being paid to be demotivated, and I honestly haven't figured this one out yet.
Since none of these seem to be true according to any analysis or experiments I've seen, I'll pass on this one.
If the stated purpose is:
1) to shrink government, not grow government.
2)Eliminate every other social program
3)Eliminate most of the civil service who otherwise would be administering those programs
4)Eliminate most labour laws, particularly minium wage
5)Oulaw labour unions, since they would no longer be necessary
6)Total spending would actually go down not up
7)It removes any possibilities of buying elections by promising more free stuff by increasingly taking it away from those who don't vote for them at every election. Governments can get back to governance, instead of redistribution.(Which sounds ironic given the topic, but if this was a one and done deal, then forever more, there would be no more freebie promises, instead of the creeping socialism we have now, where each party tries to out promise the other.
8)We find some way to keep everyone motivated in spite of being paid to be demotivated, and I honestly haven't figured this one out yet.
Since none of these seem to be true according to any analysis or experiments I've seen, I'll pass on this one.
Comment