• You will need to login or register before you can post a message. If you already have an Agriville account login by clicking the login icon on the top right corner of the page. If you are a new user you will need to Register.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Where will the diesel fuel come from if we do replace gasoline engines with EV's?

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #21
    Originally posted by hedgehog View Post
    I did that calculation years ago
    25% of your land is needed to grow the oil u need to fo the work
    Horses needed roughly the same
    My calculation this year is it cost us 2% of gross revenue for fuel. 14% for fertilizer.

    Cheers
    Last edited by TOM4CWB; Oct 16, 2022, 01:42.

    Comment


      #22
      Lets do ball parks and be generous all in imperial gallons. At seeding time tractor is 23gal/hr at 30 acres an hour or so with tenders, transporting, burnoff lets call it 1.5 gal an acre, incrop spraying lets call it 2 passes maybe 0.3 gal an acre, harvest and grain movement more like 2 gal/acre. Maybe a bit of field work .7 gal. So 4.5 gal or about 17l an acre for the year. If one bushel of canola produces 20l that should do it. So about 2.5% of a 40 bus canola crop would supply all the energy required by the equipment to produce it. If a guy wants to burn canola oil better hang onto that pre year 2000 iron with mechanical fuel pumps, electronic systems are a bit more fuel picky.
      Last edited by biglentil; Oct 16, 2022, 02:25.

      Comment


        #23
        So if yearly production cycle ( or field equipment fuel requirements) are 17 liters per acre x .50 cents per liter = $8.50 acre

        Plus all the carbon credits, what revenue would be generated?

        It would smell good

        Comment


          #24
          Originally posted by AlbertaFarmer5 View Post
          Railroads would be the low hanging fruit, already electrified in many parts of the world. Just need overhead wires. Using existing proven technology. I haven't heard a word about that in any discussions about a climate emergency.

          Which would be cheaper and easier, converting a diesel electric locomotive to full electric with overhead wires along a fixed route, or trying to build batteries large enough to power farm machinery, plus the associated charging infrastructure, plus the necessary reduntacy to allow time for charging, let alone the cost of retrofitting or replacing the existing fleet.

          As of today, the hyped up F150 EV can't even tow a trailer any useful distance, but now some are claiming we should have electric tractors etc? People cannot even fathom just how much energy is in the ~1000L of diesel that fits within a cubic meter fuel tank, and just how much larger that would have to be using current battery technology.

          I think I might have posted this before, but when the Soviets were determined to electrify everything, that included tractors, and they did build some that ran on extension cords. Mandated top down bureaucracy at its best. Not much less insane than current policies.
          1000L of diesel is 10,000kWh or 10MWh.
          1000L of diesel cost is $1500 roughly
          10,000 kWh cost is $2000.
          Electricity is 33% MORE expensive than diesel.

          Electric powertrain would be 80-90% efficient vs diesel at 35% efficiency. Electricity is already more expensive than gas/diesel at todays prices when purchasing an equivalent amount.

          Comment


            #25
            Originally posted by ALBERTAFARMER4 View Post
            1000L of diesel is 10,000kWh or 10MWh.
            1000L of diesel cost is $1500 roughly
            10,000 kWh cost is $2000.
            Electricity is 33% MORE expensive than diesel.

            Electric powertrain would be 80-90% efficient vs diesel at 35% efficiency. Electricity is already more expensive than gas/diesel at todays prices when purchasing an equivalent amount.
            Lets look at this a bit farther. A horsepower is defined as 745 watts. A typical 80ft drill and cart will do best with a 600hp tractor typically operating around 80% engine load or 480hp conditions depending. 480hp X 745 = thats 357kw/hr. Now lets use your highside estimate of 90% efficient electrical drivetrain. Typical rig probably operates at least 12hrs a day. So 12x357/0.9 = 4760KWH battery is required. Lets assume they could have a battery that large fit somewhere. The new Ford Lightning pickup has a 131KWH battery for example and when towing a medium sized trailer has a range of around 100miles. The new Electric Bobcat is claimed to last upto 4hr but am hearing 2hrs is more real world.

            Ok so now the problem charging the massive 4760kwh battery. The best charging efficiency for a Tesla is 89% due to heat from the inverter and wire loss. So 5348000 watts are required from the grid source. Lets say the farm has a 400amp service even though I think a 200amp service is probably more typical. 400ampsx240volts= 96000 watts/hr. So to charge that battery (5348000/96000) = 56hrs of charge time and during that time not even a single lightbulb in the farm yard could be turned on.

            Battery operated tractors are a pipe dream imo.

            Comment


              #26
              please don't bring facts/realities/physics into the discussion
              these green sheep know way more than the experts

              Comment


                #27
                Originally posted by biglentil View Post
                Lets look at this a bit farther. A horsepower is defined as 745 watts. A typical 80ft drill and cart will do best with a 600hp tractor typically operating around 80% engine load or 480hp conditions depending. 480hp X 745 = thats 357kw/hr. Now lets use your highside estimate of 90% efficient electrical drivetrain. Typical rig probably operates at least 12hrs a day. So 12x357/0.9 = 4760KWH battery is required. Lets assume they could have a battery that large fit somewhere. The new Ford Lightning pickup has a 131KWH battery for example and when towing a medium sized trailer has a range of around 100miles. The new Electric Bobcat is claimed to last upto 4hr but am hearing 2hrs is more real world.

                Ok so now the problem charging the massive 4760kwh battery. The best charging efficiency for a Tesla is 89% due to heat from the inverter and wire loss. So 5348000 watts are required from the grid source. Lets say the farm has a 400amp service even though I think a 200amp service is probably more typical. 400ampsx240volts= 96000 watts/hr. So to charge that battery (5348000/96000) = 56hrs of charge time and during that time not even a single lightbulb in the farm yard could be turned on.

                Battery operated tractors are a pipe dream imo.
                Thanks for doing the math. In case you haven't noticed, the cheerleaders aren't big fans of math.

                Your example includes only one tractor running half a day. Around here, when mother nature cooperates however breifly, it is more like 24 hours per day. And not one tractor, but multiple machines, tillage, rolling, harrowing, spraying, seed and fert trucks. Plus all the automobiles for transportation. Plus places are already outlawing home heating and cooking with gas, so add that plus clothes dryers and water heaters to the electrical load.

                There might be one 400 Amp service on a farm, doubtful there are services that size at every field edge, so now that machine has to travel back to farm yard every time.

                Around here, I've used the heater as often as the AC during both harvest and seeding, so derate the battery life accordingly for ambient air temp, and heater usage.

                On the other hand, assuming we achieve fully autonomous farm equipment, it could be fleets of very small machines rather than carrying 1000 bushels of seed across the field all day, so there would be some energy savings there.


                I just looked up the energy density of a battery in a Tesla model 3. If that scales up linearly to the tractor above, it only needs to weigh a little over 40,000 lbs. So just swapping batteries when they need recharging, instead of going back to the yard to charge will be hardly any more difficult than it is in the Milwaukee impact wrench, just need a 40+ ton crane on standby.

                Couldn't find the physical size of a Tesla model 3 battery, but found the energy per volume of a powerwall battery. By that measure, the battery size for the 4wd tractor only needs to be 95.73 cu meters in size.
                I don't think in cu meters, so I converted to bushels, 2860 bushels would do the job. So the equivalent of towing around the biggest grain cart in the industry and almost half more again. Mount that in place of the fuel tank and it will do wonders for the field of vision from the cab.
                Last edited by AlbertaFarmer5; Oct 17, 2022, 15:57.

                Comment


                  #28
                  Can you imagine
                  Chuck and some others on here think it can work
                  Astounding to say the least

                  Comment


                    #29
                    Ethanol can be used in Diesel engines, 1.7x diesel energy density. No particulates, Nox reduced over 93%… same power output as normal Diesel engines… no after treatment needed like diesels need now.





                    There is no need to go to electrical batteries for our equipment energy supply on our farms. Ethanol is less expensive than diesel on an energy basis right now.

                    Cheers

                    Comment


                      #30
                      Originally posted by TOM4CWB View Post
                      Ethanol can be used in Diesel engines, 1.7x diesel energy density. No particulates, Nox reduced over 93%… same power output as normal Diesel engines… no after treatment needed like diesels need now.





                      There is no need to go to electrical batteries for our equipment energy supply on our farms. Ethanol is less expensive than diesel on an energy basis right now.

                      Cheers
                      Seems like a workable solution.

                      I'm sure the food versus fuel debate won't be reignited during a time of supposed global famine.

                      Comment

                      • Reply to this Thread
                      • Return to Topic List
                      Working...