• You will need to login or register before you can post a message. If you already have an Agriville account login by clicking the login icon on the top right corner of the page. If you are a new user you will need to Register.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

If there is a market crash coming, what forward planning should we be doing?

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    If there is a market crash coming, what forward planning should we be doing?

    Lots of chatter lately about the impending collapse of markets and general financial issues world wide. This post is not about if we think it is happening, but what should we be doing if we think that way. This is more about ideas and opportunities.

    Concept as I understand it is a market sell off to raise cash and then a general market run down as the rats get off the ship. Then perhaps the govt prints more money to stimulate the economy and lower interest rates to further stimulate the economy. All cycles that have happened repeatedly before, but I have not always paid attention.

    So thinking about this as a grain farmer.

    It seems that commodity prices drop first in the recession/depression, so do we think that we are currently in the low commodity price part of the recession or are we thinking the low prices are ahead of us? I use "we" meaning the group reading and responding. Normal recessions seem to have money move from the dropping stock markets into commodities. Obviously if the lows are here, then waiting with grain sales will provide equal to higher opportunities and avoid pricing fall grain sales. If the lows are ahead, then sales sooner will still be higher than what is coming.

    So if we have any money in the stock market, perhaps it should move to a new home. But what new home? Most RRSP's are exposed to the stock market and some mutual funds can only invest in stocks. Again, this whole post is about if we believe there is a correction coming, what to do, to save some of our wealth, not to say there is no correction coming. And hopefully there is a strategy that deals easily with both scenarios.

    I would assume that in a normal recession that the finished goods price gets hurt first and then prices drop along the chain back to the first supplier. So assuming that food costs are high and that is slowing the orders and prices for grains, can we assume that the inputs for grain (fertilizer, chemical, machinery, etc) will soon be dropping in price?

    Hopefully my thinking is correct here in thinking that any cash on hand or commodities expected to increase in value will be better sitting put for a while as they might buy more once a recession starts. Now if it is cash, is a GIC the investment, or is the bond market something to look at? I have no idea how risky the bond market is?

    Then once the recession is deep and the gov't starts printing money or doing the quantative easing we want to have our money out of GIC's or cash and invested in hard goods that we need or back in other investments such as the stock market (because prices will have been run down). Does this sound like a good strategy? After the printing presses ran for covid, this massive inflation on everything, finally made my brain think that perhaps gov't printing presses have more to do with economic recovery than I realized. But maybe I am wrong.

    The rich seem to have this market up/down thing figured out and have strategies in place to deal with it as the cycles repeat often. Poorer managers like me seem to just have more/less money in my pocket and have never really thought that the decisions I make could heavily influence that.

    Now some lived through the bad times of 1980's and early 1990's and have been predicting the same thing for 45 years and by being ultra conservative have hurt their finances greatly. I don't really want doomsday type answers and discussion as much a what to do best for the normal recessions that seem to happen every 6-8 years lately.

    Sorry, this is so long, but I have 10 years left in my career and would like to take advantage of markets by trying to be proactive.
    Last edited by poorboy; Jan 6, 2025, 11:58.

    #2
    Grain flow since harvest has been very steady so I don't think inventories are enough to push prices farther down least not in this area. Still unstable world crap going on so you got to feed the wars etc. etc. Lots of fert was put on before freeze up (record for local dealer) so that has been priced, spent. A hedge against pending doom I guess would be buy RB shares.

    Comment


      #3
      Grains are nearly record low when compared to almost every other asset right now.
      Perhaps the play is to short stocks, real estate, other. Commodities etc. as a hedge against grain, rather than shorting (forward) selling the grain at historic low relative ratios.

      Comment


        #4
        Every time there was a threat of a market correction I would ask the Finacial Advisor about moving to cash(away from the stock market).... all they'd ever say was stay invested. Some of those "threats" never materialized. And the "corrections" I did live through recovered and investments went even further...
        then they'd show me the chart displaying that theory.

        I think it's much deeper than that. What equities(stocks) are the investor holding and how old is the investor? Depending on the depth of the correction and how old you are.... do you have enough time for them to recover.

        Advice to one investor may not be suitable for another...

        Guessing exit and entry points, whose good at it?

        Comment


          #5
          To add to my post above.
          I'm simply responding to the original poster under the assumption that markets are about to crash. Not offering an opinion on this outcome.
          If one assumes that is true, then I'm saying that almost any other asset has further to fall than grains do. So staying long grain ( in the bins, in the field or in the seed bag), while going short any other asset, assuming that the historical gap will close, even if both go down, or both go up, you will still come out ahead.

          Comment


            #6
            I am totally unsure about what is coming. Typical inflation and recession cycle seems to have us close to the bottom of grain prices. These bottoms can hang on for 1, 2 or more seasons though. I am just wondering what a person should be thinking or looking at doing if markets change.

            I am like AF5 and thinking that grain prices are low (as well as oil, gas, baltic freight rates, etc.) and these commodity indicators would tell me that we are closing in on the lows for some leading indicator commodities and most likely there will be a small stock market drop coming. How long grain prices will be low is the big unknown. If only a few months, then delaying a portion of my sales for a while is probably a good thing. If it is a 2-3 year low price situation for grains, then I should be selling grain soon as my bins can not store 2 crops and my bank account is not big enough to keep farming without some cash flow.

            Credit is so available today that I do not see a big farm crunch coming like we had in the 80's and 90's. But a small recession certainly looks possible.

            Can someone explain the bond market to me as a novice investor? I am told that bonds appreciate in value when interest rates drop, so they look like a good place to put a little money to watch. Do I buy mutual funds that specialize in bonds or do online trading platforms just have a place you buy bonds? Or are bonds like stocks and you have to very carefully pick the right one/ones?

            Comment


              #7
              Im not going to say i totally disagree BUT some crop prices are actually pretty strong..
              oats for instance is good value.. so are most legume crops... hay.. malt barley isnt horrid.

              it really seems like the low input crops are strong values...while the high input crops are poor value compared to inputs.

              I think we were just spoiled with big cheques for a couple yrs and people forgot how less than what.... 5 yrs ago... oats were being bought for less than 3 bucks...

              The real nut kicker is equipment. It has become so expensive..which has increased rent ..etc etc further down the line.
              the land that we rented for 50 bucks 10 yrs ago isnt any more productive today when we are paying double that. Its competition and hogwash heresay that had really fudged up the program. And funny enough... most of the land that i know of that has been snaked out from under people ( jacking up rent) has always seemed to follow the high bidding farms recent equipment purchase!

              i think there are too many mouths to feed to see a real recession in farming.


              Margins are similiar... just the numbers are smaller..

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by goalieguy847 View Post
                Im not going to say i totally disagree BUT some crop prices are actually pretty strong..


                I think we were just spoiled with big cheques for a couple yrs and people forgot how less than what.... 5 yrs ago... oats were being bought for less than 3 bucks...
                Agree. We were very profitable during the low price years prior to the recent spike.
                Prices have settled into a much higher range following the spike. My expenses (other than land) haven't increased as much as income has. But there is no shiny paint here.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Not meaning to derail a good topic.
                  Farm long enough you'll see 1 or 2 bad downturns.
                  Now ask yourself what would you do if your career were nearing it's end.

                  Comment

                  • Reply to this Thread
                  • Return to Topic List
                  Working...