Pandiana, I would have to say that both have their strong points and it is hard to decide which would be better because we have really enjoyed both and both have done well in keeping the coyotes at bay.
The key to either one of them is that they have to be bonded to their sheep (or goats or whatever they are going to look after). They can't be bonded to you because then they won't do their job as effectively. You want them staying with the animals they are protecting.
The livestock guardian works on what is "normal" in his environment and any changes cause him to be on the alert. We once left a truck in the field because we were fencing and it was so out of the norm that the dog wouldn't quit barking at it until we brought it back up to the yard.
We socialized ours to accept people once he was told it was okay for them to be around his sheep and a friend of ours once pointed out to us that the dog always stayed between him and the sheep, but his little boy could have the run of the place. We didn't notice it, but it was interesting to watch.
Being a dog lover, I would have to say my final choice would be the dog. The kind of money you are talking about seems kind of high but things always increase in value. Choose what breed that you think will work for you. If you want more info and ideas on breeds, e-mail me privately and I'd be happy to answer your questions.
Linda
The key to either one of them is that they have to be bonded to their sheep (or goats or whatever they are going to look after). They can't be bonded to you because then they won't do their job as effectively. You want them staying with the animals they are protecting.
The livestock guardian works on what is "normal" in his environment and any changes cause him to be on the alert. We once left a truck in the field because we were fencing and it was so out of the norm that the dog wouldn't quit barking at it until we brought it back up to the yard.
We socialized ours to accept people once he was told it was okay for them to be around his sheep and a friend of ours once pointed out to us that the dog always stayed between him and the sheep, but his little boy could have the run of the place. We didn't notice it, but it was interesting to watch.
Being a dog lover, I would have to say my final choice would be the dog. The kind of money you are talking about seems kind of high but things always increase in value. Choose what breed that you think will work for you. If you want more info and ideas on breeds, e-mail me privately and I'd be happy to answer your questions.
Linda
Comment