Who's going to PAY for it??

[r.reid]

emerald 1. Think about this.

My ansestors came to this uncharted land on a boat with NOTHING, not even shoes. They settled in Sask. (on my Dads side) and south western Nebraska (on my Moms side). They fought disease, death, bugs, the 30s, and what ever else, and made something of themselves. Nobody gave them anything.

My point to this is simple. Everyone in one point of their background has had it rough. But the Indians are the only ones that use the same old arguement over, and over; (so and so happened X number of years ago, that has nothing to do with todays times WHAT-SO-EVER, so you have to pay me).

Yes it is to bad what happend to them X number of years ago. But get over it already and get on with it like everybody else has had to. Cause quite frankly the system can't support this much longer (in Sask. anyhow) and it's going to come down on top of everybodies heads.

We WON'T be having the same arguement in 50 years like one of your last posts stated. Cause the ratio of people putting in the system as apposed to taking out of the system is getting smaller and smaller every year.

It's simple math 101 emerald 1.

[cakadu]

I'm just throwing this out there, what would it look like if the first nations were required to pay taxes? Would that work towards making them more responsible?

What, if any, difference is there between the fellow who buys cattle etc. in order to avoid paying taxes and someone who is tax exempt? They are both still not paying taxes, while the rest of us are.

What about the big corporations, who if even required to pay 10% tax, would add significantly to the revenues of this country. Think about each of the big 5 banks. Each of them boasts profits per quarter into the hundreds of million, if not billion per quarter. 10% of a billion dollars would go a long way wouldn't it?

It's been my experience that unless you've walked in someones shoes for a while, it's hard to know what it is like and what you would be like. Look at the welfare system. You see people abusing the welfare system all the time and people who grow up in that system sometimes go on to become the next generation.

I agree, it is time to put the past behind us and move on. It's only been in the last while that there have been concerted efforts to help aboriginal peoples get the help that they need, after at least a couple of hundred of abuse. It won't go away over night, but we can sure try to make a difference, one person or one group at a time.

[r.reid]

"What, if any, difference is there between the fellow who buys cattle etc. in order to avoid paying taxes and someone who is tax exempt? They are both still not paying taxes, while the rest of us are."

A BIG BIG differance.

1. The person slaving his/her butt off pulling a calf in the middle of the night in the cold,,,is trying to get ahead. (It is called CAPITALISM)

2. The person that isn't paying taxes because a paper says they don't have to,,,is not getting ahead and is infact going backwards. They don't have to worry about the person pulling that frozen calf out of a cow. Why should they.

3. The one with the cows, or crop, or bussiness; creates jobs and spin-offs benifitting everyone around them. This leads to more dollars being spent in the stores, and gas stations, restaurants and car dealerships or whatever (again CAPITALISM).

4. The one not paying tax because a piece paper says they doesn't have too,,,,does not create any of the things I mentioned in point # 3. But in fact they take away.

To relate the two is completely wrong and careless.

[r.reid]

r.reid, I don't know much about the first nations people in Saskatchewan but in Alberta there are many that do pull calves in the middle of the night, as part of their duties toward the band they are part of. For those that cannot work due to illness etc., many are required to clean the houses of the elderly natives on the reserve, do do their part in caring for their aging population. Not every first nations band are lazy and uselss. As far as the comment about agreeing with the residential schools, how many of us would want to be scooped up in our backyards, taken on an airplane far away and not see our families for years, be separated from our siblings and whipped because we spoke the only language we knew. Believe me, I know people that had this happen to them, and they are only in their late fifties now. Many have gone on to make significant accomplishments and in some cases haven't ever found their families or if they have it hasn't been until they were well into their twenties or thirties. I would be shocked at anyone that would agree with that.

I am not disagreeing with the suggestions that there needs to be some major changes to the legislation that governs our first nations people. But it will not come about without much controversy and certainly not without huge legal battles that will possibly cost our government more than the status quo.

[r.reid]

That is great that they are self suffecient and making a go of it in places in Alberta

But in Saskatchewan for every 1 "success" story there are 10 miserable failures, that nobody wants to talk about. I too have seen the results of Indian bands trying to farm and run cows. The smashed combines, the dead cows, the empty grain bins, the broken fences that remain after it failed. Makes one throw-up.

Someone paid for it.

Question: Emerald 1, does the Indian band you speak of pay income tax like their non-native counterparts? If not then why?

You know what's really sad? It is the Indians that do try to get ahead and then the other "dead-beat" Indians try to bring them down.

[cakadu]

I should have been a little more specific rreid about the guy having cattle to avoid paying taxes. It is not too likely that he is out there in the middle of the night pulling calves, he likely has someone custom doing it for him. It is the person who many on this site have said shouldn't be in the cattle business because he is the "hobby" farmer and doesn't really care if he/she ever makes any money on cattle. The poor fellow out there in the middle of the night in all kinds of weather is often trying to make a living solely from the farm.

What sorts of resources are there in Sask to help the natives? What sort of effort is being made in each of the communities? From what you describe, there appears to be a significant difference between our two provinces, some of which can be attributed to the wealth that comes from the oil revenue.

On the other hand, there are bands that live in abject poverty because there is no treaty money, no oil revenue and no hope for where they are. How do we help those people become more productive and most importantly, value themselves?

[cakadu]

The natives that seem to fall through the cracks here in AB are the ones that leave the reserves or do not have treaty status. Many of those young people go to the larger centres and some do get involved with the wrong type of lifestyle. The problems on reserves with families are usually due to drug and alcohol abuse....but the native population certainly does not have a monopoly on those vices !!!

[r.reid]

Cakadu and Emerald 1...You are totally missing my point.

Why should they need oil $$$ or treaty $$$ to make it. Is it because they are different?? Is it because they are stupid and can't work??? NO, it isn't. It is just become to easy to sit by the mail box and wait for that free check to come.

It is attitudes like yours that are making them the way they are.

Nobody appreciates anything if you just give it to them. Because then they just become to expect it (like now). They must EARN it.

Cakadu, you want to know what is here to "help" them become better.
1. Free schooling (a doctor, lawyer, rocket scientist, whatever).
2. Money to live on while they go to school
3. Free (reserve) fully equipt housing.
4. Job priority based on race (quota system).

Probably similar in Alberta???

There should be no need of the problems that we now face NO NEED OF IT.

[cakadu]

There will always be those that try to pull others down, no matter what you do. I agree emrald, having problems with drugs and alcohol is not limited to a particular race, color, social standing or wealth. It happens in the best of families and more often than one might think.

Anyone that gets a hand up at the right time generally goes on to do better. Sadly, there are those that don't have anyone there to give them a hand, a kind word or help of any sort.

The solutions have to be generated with a great deal of input from the natives - without that, we will once again be telling them what we think is right. They should be allowed to determine what is right for themselves.

[cakadu]

The oil money and the treaty money are what have lead to some of the problems - I agree with you there.

If you remove any incentive, then there are problems, no matter who you are.

Many of the younger generation have had "things" given to them because their parents could afford it, the kids wanted it and it's easier to provide things than what kids need and that is stability, boundaries and most of all knowing that they are loved. We have seen a whole host of societal problems arising because many kids today expect things and don't recognize or appreciate the value of working for them. I'm not saying that all kids are bad, in fact the opposite as there are some really great kids out there.

We must seek first to understand (and this could be cultural differences, the feelings that you get when you've been treated poorly for many years or even your entire life etc.) and then help them to make lasting changes. All of us want to feel good about ourselves.