Federal Court rules Emergency Act use ‘Unreasonable’

[blackpowder]

Wrongway
I think that underlines something.
Do we have a federal police force?
A National Guard?
Can the RCMP be all things?
(Several issues are showing we need a rework there.)
City police surely cannot and should not.
Even a good law needs a clear and safe enacting force. It also circumvents the risks of a weak, cowardly, or malevolent sitting government. A lot to cover there, starting with the Constitution, basic Govt structures, and then moving on to checks and balances.

From the start of the Vid everyone bumbled along. From the PM on down. The PM shat himself on day one and every day after.

Perhaps the closure of a Federal port of entry should be met with immediate force whether NFU or anyone else. Parliament?? Well, it functioned in England during the Blitz and the V2s.........

[agstar77]

If not used ,why have it? Perceived or not no one was willing to use force to evict those rabble. Abusing rights of protest is bad for everyone with a legitimate grievance.

[AlbertaFarmer5]

If not used ,why have it? Perceived or not no one was willing to use force to evict those rabble. Abusing rights of protest is bad for everyone with a legitimate grievance.

And who is in charge of deciding what is a legitimate grievance?

[fjlip]

Thanks, we mostly here RABBLE...abusing is what the STUPID mandates were! Accomplished SFA, discarded eventually. Clearly some are opposed to the freedom we want/had!

[wrongway]

Wrongway
I think that underlines something.
Do we have a federal police force?
A National Guard?
Can the RCMP be all things?
(Several issues are showing we need a rework there.)
City police surely cannot and should not.
Even a good law needs a clear and safe enacting force. It also circumvents the risks of a weak, cowardly, or malevolent sitting government. A lot to cover there, starting with the Constitution, basic Govt structures, and then moving on to checks and balances.

From the start of the Vid everyone bumbled along. From the PM on down. The PM shat himself on day one and every day after.

Perhaps the closure of a Federal port of entry should be met with immediate force whether NFU or anyone else. Parliament?? Well, it functioned in England during the Blitz and the V2s.........

I find it very interesting that in both Canada and the US under far left governments the federal police forces(RCMP, FBI) have been weaponized to protect the governing regime. The main stream media being totally complicit in this, never calls out this fascist behavior. Indeed even warning that things will be worse if a new party is voted in. In Canada its because the media relies so much on government funding that they would no longer be able to survive with out it. I suspect the same holds true in the US. The RCMP and the judiciary must be seen to be at arms length from the Government. Sadly and even alarmingly private individuals are more and more likely to have their freedoms and property rights totally ignored and abused. Even if court cases are brought about the cost in money and time against an unfettered government bureaucracy cannot be fought by the average individual. (Liche and Barber).
For the stars and the ****s that are defending the government actions, think about this...who will fight for you when a different government comes along and decides that they don't like what you are saying and proceed to restrict your rights?

I think the only way out is for the voting public to realize that government can not and will not bestow freedom on its citizens it will only take freedom away. Rise up and demand from politicians to do better and work for us instead of against us.

[cropgrower]

trudope said he admired the basic chinese communist dictatorship , he ment it , violating the Charter , siezing bank accounts , censoring the internet etc

[blackpowder]

One thing I sense. In recent decades police and the governments responsible, have forgotten that police are citizens. Soldiers are not.
Each has unique jurisdiction and responsibility. The lines for police have become blurred.

[blackpowder]

If not used ,why have it? Perceived or not no one was willing to use force to evict those rabble. Abusing rights of protest is bad for everyone with a legitimate grievance.

One would hope a broad suspension of civil liberties necessary for sovereign protection in times of it's peril would require considerably more than an inept handling of localized protests.

[furrowtickler]

If not used ,why have it? Perceived or not no one was willing to use force to evict those rabble. Abusing rights of protest is bad for everyone with a legitimate grievance.

Sorry , undeniably unreasonable
absolutely was never a question
Gross overstep of dictatorship
Was never used in the rail blockade and should have not there either

[cropgrower]

If not used ,why have it? Perceived or not no one was willing to use force to evict those rabble. Abusing rights of protest is bad for everyone with a legitimate grievance.

Their are conditions that must be met for act to be used , them conditions were not met , thats why it was ruled unlawfull , and i cant see that being overturned , conditions were not met end of story , if it had just been used to move trucks i could mabe understand ,but still not legal as act clearly says its not to be used when their other options , and a parking problem is not a national emergency ,plenty laws in place to deal with that allready , but everything else that was done was 100% wrong

[ajl]

What is sad is that the resignation of the government has not been demanded yet. We should by now have the date of the election set. The government is supposed to uphold laws, not break them. There was nothing illegal happening at all. Convoy participate were doing what was reasonable under the circumstances. Remember keep upchuck and his ilk block. Helps remove alot of silly off Agriville.

[shtferbrains]

Former Justice Minister David Lametti resigned his Montreal seat.

That lid is getting nailed down tighter daily.

We just need Jagmeet to see it's time to take the plunge.

[cropgrower]

he deleted all his twitter the day court rulled against what they done , they know the lawsuits are coming next , am i right in saying he talked about tanks to clear protest ?

[cropgrower]

Not a word from the tyrant trudope yet , coward dont have much to say now , kinda like clueless chuck !

[TSIPP]

I hate to say it but the turd is probably the most normal person in this government, the rest of his cabinet is absolutely bonkers! The turd is extremely bonkers just not as bad as the rest, maybe? ????