An Open Letter from Economists on Canadian Carbon Pricing

[Hamloc]

The key point here is very simple. Stephen Guilbeault said climate related costs will cost the average Canadian household $2000 per year by 2050, up from $720 per year now. Both Justin Trudeau and Stephen Guilbeault infer that the trajectory of these costs are changed by the carbon tax and reducing Canada’s emissions. But this simply isn’t true. China’s and India’s future emission increases will be far larger than any decrease in Canada. Emissions don’t stop at the border, therefore the climate related costs Stephen Guilbeault talks about will be the same in 2050 whether the carbon tax in Canada exists or not. What the carbon tax will do is make energy more expensive and Canada’s economy smaller as pointed out by the PBO. If the Trudeau government was truly worried about future generations they would reduce deficit spending and therefore the future taxes on today’s youth!!!!

[Hamloc]

Chuck2, here is the excerpt from Stephen Guilbeault’s article.

[chuckChuck]

The PBO said the economy will only be slightly smaller with the carbon tax. The economists have clearly said the carbon tax is the lowest cost way to reduce emissions and that other options will cost more.

But just admit you don't want to do anything! Because like A5 says more CO2 is good for us!

[AlbertaFarmer5]

Sure A5 sure! From the guy who said asphalt is the only reason global temperatures are rising!

Denial isn't just a river in Egypt.

[chuckChuck]

Yes and denial flows through Alberta too!

[Hamloc]

The PBO said the economy will only be slightly smaller with the carbon tax. The economists have clearly said the carbon tax is the lowest cost way to reduce emissions and that other options will cost more.

But just admit you don't want to do anything! Because like A5 says more CO2 is good for us!

Chuck2 the simple reality is lowering emissions in Canada won’t do anything. It won’t change the weather, it won’t make life more affordable, it won’t make the economy grow faster. What it will do is make energy more expensive.

Chuck2, what do you believe lowering emissions in Canada will accomplish? Under Justin Trudeau the federal government now employs 100000 more people. The national debt has more than doubled!!! What has that accomplished? Owning a house has now become an unaffordable dream for the majority of young families. Per capita GDP has gone down to the same level it was back in 2014. This is Justin Trudeau’s record!

[cropgrower]

Its all part of the YOU will own notting and be happy plan

[shtferbrains]

I think Chuck must have me blocked?
When I post any data or information that is relative to the conversation he seens to not have seen or considered it.
He just goes back over the mantra he has been chanting forever.
He never answers even the simplest questions asking for his opinion on anything.
He must not see it?

[AlbertaFarmer5]

I think Chuck must have me blocked?
When I post any data or information that is relative to the conversation he seens to not have seen or considered it.
He just goes back over the mantra he has been chanting forever.
He never answers even the simplest questions asking for his opinion on anything.
He must not see it?

The quickest way to find out is to post something that he is capable of responding in classic Chuck style.
Something at his academic level and maturity.
If you have access to any 5-year-olds, you can consult them on this issue. In case it has been a while since you found yourself on the elementary school playground exchanging insults with a local bully and need a refresher on how it is done.
Alternately, you can make a post about the well documented benefits of increased co2. He can't resist responding to those.

[cropgrower]

thats what the waco liberals do ,ignore or talk a load of rubbish propaganda when asked a question , Wab Kinew here in manitoba does not want the carbon tax also , he must be anti science now too

[blackpowder]

Honestly, 1 teenager in my life is plenty. I shouldn't ever respond to this stuff. But then something really dumb is said....

[fjlip]

I think Chuck must have me blocked?
When I post any data or information that is relative to the conversation he seens to not have seen or considered it.
He just goes back over the mantra he has been chanting forever.
He never answers even the simplest questions asking for his opinion on anything.
He must not see it?

Same here, I am asking if he can READ, to answer the question, comment on a post of facts...

[AlbertaFarmer5]

Honestly, 1 teenager in my life is plenty. I shouldn't ever respond to this stuff. But then something really dumb is said....

That's what makes it so irresistible to keep responding.
Chuck tries so hard to present himself as the smartest guy in the room. And fails so spectacularly every time, then comes back for more abuse
It is so easy, and so entertaining to nudge him to reveal how little he understands the concepts he is so certain about.
The dunning Kruger effect on full display for all to see.

[chuckChuck]

Glad to see the flat earthers talking to themselves!

Their message, never trust an expert they are all wrong!

In other words education is a waste of time!

[AlbertaFarmer5]

Chuck, do you know what the Dunning Kruger effect is?
Do you know where your level of knowledge places you on the curve?