Life?

[smcgrath76]

I like that idea CS. It is along the lines of what I think needed to be done with the regional plant concept.
It could potentially be started small (one or two locals) and grow from there.
The biggest challenge to our industry domestically is probably the regulation and interprovincial pissing match in terms of trade, certfication, foodsafety, brand inspection, animal disease, etc.
I think it matches up some of KPBs vision with less gov't involvement.

[cswilson]

It's easier to think a bit smaller and grow than to think tooo big and shrink. You have to crawl before you can walk-I think this franchise concept would be easier to attract outside investment too also. It's always nicer to float a new venture with somebody elses capital. Most of use are better at raising calves than we are at managing butcher shops and arranging venture capital.

[grassfarmer]

I'm not sure I understand this concept of yours cswilson. What you are talking about are essentially what I would call butcher shops - locally owned or franchised stores selling beef or meat only? These are what we grew up with in the UK, every town had one or two. How widespread are these type of butcher shops in Canada? do they exist in urban areas or only in some rural towns? In the UK they have largely gone the way of the dodo as most younger, and all urban consumers shop at supermarkets. Isn't this the case in Canada also? From what I read it seems that even the straight cuts of beef on the supermarket shelf are an endangered species to be replaced with prepacked "meal solutions" ie a tiny quantity of beef bulked up with some vegetables and sauce and charged at the same price per pound as a decent steak!

[cswilson]

Well the two we have here sell other stuff also-they seem to be competeing fine against the two big box grocery stores in town. If the concept was marketed right it would fly I'm sure.To build a megaplant to compete with Cargill you have to become just like them-then it's same s..t different pile for the producer.

[spudchucker]

No offense meant but I don't like the idea. You say that any young guy could just buy an older guys allocation.
I would like to milk cows again but there is no way that I could afford to pay the $30,000 per cow for quota. I small herd of milk cows these days is 40 which means 1.2 MM before I even put a cent into facilities, animals, land, machinery, etc.
This would go the same way and would ensure that only rich europeans and inherited farms could afford to be in the industry.
Too many of these policies (supply management) are meant to keep the status quo and protect old peoples retirement funds while keeping new entrants out.
Why make the beef business the same way?

[nicolaas]

The biggest problem with the supply management system is that only the rich can enter the industry since dairys were allowed to include the quota as an asset..and activley buy/sell a 'worthless' piece of paper. The trend for the supply managed system in canada is towards fewer but bigger farms, as the big guys buy up the quota. Isn't this the same thing that is happening in the USA dairy industry without the quota? Not to mention the grain/beef farms in Canada? I think we have to focus on getting more money out of the existing system. THat is the only way to save the farm in the long run.....how to do that is the problem. I figure the government would love to get rid of supply management,a major trade irritant, but then they may be on the hook for billions for compensation for the now worthles quota.

[grassfarmer]

Quota cost needn't be a deterrant to new entrants - this post started of quoting $100 per share to buy in to the project that could be fixed as the cost of "quota" for eternity.
Seems to me the "free market economy" we have already is ensuring "only rich europeans and inherited farms could afford to be in the industry" - and oil money people.

[spudchucker]

Do you seriously think it would stay at $100 per head if there is a guaranteed margin? When the quota exchange system first started in my home province quota was about $1500/kg. It is now 30K .
If there was no quota system then I would at least have a chance in the business. With the quota system, it guarantees that I will never have a chance unless I have a million dollars burning a hole in my back pocket.

[grassfarmer]

Some of the latter quotas that were introduced in Europe had a fixed value at time of creation set by the regulaterly bodies and they worked fine. They only increase in value in an uncontrolled marketplace where high margins can be earned. I don't think that that would really apply to the project we are discussing here. If, like the dairy world, you could keep 40 cows on a quarter and make $50,000 a year then the "quota" would be worth bidding up.

[cswilson]

How would quota affect guys who run stocker cattle-develop breeding heifers-etc. I can see it just another means for the government trying to whittle everybody's peg to fit in their preordained hole-when you try and legislate it so nobody fails very few succeed. If the dairy industry is so rosy why are their dairies going under in their supply managed utopia. A quota system would be good for me because I'd get it grandfathered but for my kids-can't see that happening. There'd be more ways to inflate the price of it and hide it than you can shake a stick at.